Reconstruction talk:Proto-Indo-European/bʰlew-

Latin
🇨🇬 looks more like tudati-type present. Not sure why the proto-Italic form is reconstructed as simple thematic? Similar thing happens with 🇨🇬 :, so it may be regular? Bezimenen (talk) 12:43, 28 November 2019 (UTC)
 * It should be under a ye-present, per 535. -- 22:51, 28 November 2019 (UTC)
 * That's questionable. We need further evidence before declaring it ye-present (which is secondary in nature in the first place). The whole formation R[0]-ew- is a construction of itself. It's not particularly likely that the first derivative which a language creates with it is a secondary ye-present. In general, early PIE employed -y- as a default imperfective marker and -w- as a default perfective marker. Mixing them from the get-go is logically inconsistent. Bezimenen (talk) 12:56, 29 November 2019 (UTC)
 * you're spewing a lot of here on the project that isn't supported academia, nor this project. My sources for my edits on this page are there, including the ye-present from Sihler. You also seem to have a problem properly reading sources, because Rix, whom you mistakenly cite, claims the s-aorists are secondary, and if you knew anything about Greek (and PII), you would know that they add prefixes to their aorists (not to even mention that *Hbʰlew- would be an invalid root). You also need to stop just making up definitions -- I trust Beekes definitions of Greek terms over anything you're pulling from your head. As for the final laryngeal you insist should be in the reconstruction, laryngeals are lost in a VCHy position. --  15:19, 29 November 2019 (UTC)
 * Read again Sihler, p. 522:

Primative verbs in -έω-, mostly presents of the simple thematic class in origin ... πλέω ...
 * Are you blind or what? And you are the one, who is insisting on the laryngeal, not me! Bezimenen (talk)

Coda -H-
Before you brute force your obnoxious opinion again, I demand you provide evidence for this -H- in Latin and Greek! Do not just quote LIV!!! I want concrete evidence, comparative analysis, other examples of the environment -CewH- (which is primative!)... And stop selectively quoting sources when they agree with your views and other times disregarding them completely when they don't. Bezimenen (talk) 15:18, 29 November 2019 (UTC)