Talk:汐実子

RFV discussion: December 2013–September 2014
On 15 June 2008 a certain user added a huge number of given names by (one might guess) searching the given names dictionary in WWWJDIC with the keyword "実", unless this user happens to know a huge number of names which all just happen to contain the same character and half of which are impossible to verify. This is one of those which gets under 1000 hits, all of which are online dictionaries, "name recipe" websites, or otherwise dubious sources. I've checked all the "Yumiko"s and these appear bogus:


 * 汐実子 (heading)
 * 生実子
 * 弓実子
 * 諭実子
 * ゆ実子 - A mix of kana and kanji is common in female given names, but in such a case, only the final 子 is written in kanji. This type of combination is very unusual.
 * 宙実子
 * 幸実子

Haplogy (話) 01:30, 17 December 2013 (UTC)
 * Delete all. It is all right if we have ゆみこ. — T AKASUGI Shinji (talk) 06:06, 27 August 2014 (UTC)
 * Delete. None of the names listed seems to come with enough instances we can verify. Assuming three citations are needed for including given names, I agree with deleting the listed entries - non-existing or extremely rare names as far as I can see. I found zero or only one reliable instance for each on the web: 生実子 (Kimiko, not Yumiko), 弓美子 (Yumiko), 諭実子 (probably Yumiko), 幸実子 (probably Yumiko). Whym (talk) 12:18, 3 September 2014 (UTC)

Failed. bd2412 T 14:07, 3 September 2014 (UTC)