Talk:kaleng

Via Portuguese
Are you sure the Indonesian/Malay word is from Portuguese, instead of some native origin, as assumed on the page of, and see also the toponym with its odd alternative form  homonymous to the Arabic word for “fortress” itself of dubious relation to this word?

I fear your Portuguese claim is only copied from a book written by some Western smarty-pants who sorted the words together in his armchair and found it convenient to explain everything from Arabic, because thereby he enters a field with which he does not have to deal with, though the Arabic is probably a borrowing from the area. But since you are a native Indonesian speaker you maybe have more information. Fay Freak (talk) 19:41, 26 September 2021 (UTC)